Why I don’t like the iPhone and HATE the iPod touch(this entry is rated R for strong language and drug use)
Honestly, I was sold on Apple when I bought my first iPod almost 5 years ago. I have encouraged everyone I know to move towards Apple products, especially the iPod because I simply love it. But since the debut of the iPhone and the subsequent release of the iPod touch I have been terribly disappointed in Apple’s most recent choices. Whilst the design and aesthetics of the iPhone/iPod touch are remarkable(they truly are beautiful products) there are several technical things that instantly turned me right off the iPhone and its non-phone brother. I had a chance this summer to play around with an iPhone for several hours, and this is what I’ve found out both from that experience and from those of my friends.
First, the iPhone: it has no Instant Messaging and a 2 megapixel camera a but no MMS. Also, Safari doesn’t even let you upload the pictures on the phone to the web. You can send them in an email all you want, but if you just took a picture and you want to go into Safari and add it to your facebook page or whatever, you’re SOL. I can’t send picture messages from my 2005 razr to my friends who have brand new iPhones using MMS. I have to email it to them so they can go into Mail and look at it. While this is all well and good, to me it betrays the point of a cameraphone. Also, if you’re not on an 802.11 wireless network the Internet is just god damned slow. Slow enough to the point that you want to give up on it entirely and just go home to your computer. Just try using that shitty OSD keyboard to punch in web addresses, Google searches, or even a blog entry. For fuck sake, Opera Mini running on my razrv3 is faster than iPhone’s Safari and has easier to use input methods.
Another beef I have is the fact that you have to plug it in to sync. Having to plug it in to charge is one thing, but it has Bluetooth… so give me a break. I can sync my razr with Bluetooth all I want. So shouldn’t I be able to with an iPhone?
And just so we have this clear, it’s an iPod and a phone… that means it plays music and does phone calls, right? So why can’t I set it to use any song I have on it as a ring tone? Why do I have to pay $0.99 for a song from the iTunes store and then turn around and pay another $0.99 to use it as a ringtone? Fuck you!
Going back to the keyboard, it’s just impossible to text quickly with one hand on the iPhone. Oh and p.s.—could at&t be bothered to offer lost/stolen insurance on it?
Those are what I see as some major flaws with the iPhone and why I didn’t run out and get one right away.
A short rundown of why the iPod touch sucks: First off the price is ridiculous. The 16GB model is $399. An iPod classic with TEN TIMES the storage is fifty dollars less! What a stupid fucking waste of money.
And yes, I understand that the touch uses more expensive flash memory than the 2.5″ SATA laptop hard drive the iPod classic uses, but again… for fuck sake! I just can’t overemphasize the price disparity here, coupled with an abysmal misstep in terms of features:
WiFi store? Pretty cool. Safari? Awesome. YouTube? Well alright, whatever–if you really want it. No Mail? Lame. No iChat? stupid. On screen keyboard? You know my feelings already. No scroll wheel? Fuck you.
That’s right. I said Fuck You to Apple, which was once one of my favorite companies. Now I think they have made giant missteps and blunders with these two devices. I openly tell people who ask me about either one not to buy them due to most of the reasons outlined above.. In my view they are simply bad products—even worse: they’re two of the worst things Apple as ever come up with.
Moreover, the reason why I feel so strongly about this has to do with one simple thing: the scroll wheel. In my opinion the scroll wheel is hands down the single greatest UI innovation since the invention of the mouse. It’s a simple and elegant solution to the problems presented by the iPod. It’s just a great idea. This is the number one thing I want to see resolved before I even contemplate purchasing an iPhone or iPod touch. An on-screen scroll wheel I can “slide” up with my finger when I wish to use it seems to me the best idea. Just let me have the option so I can wheel through my music/movies/contacts/web pages/etc with a single thumb like before. What a terrible mistake. I seriously hope it turns out to be a single-gen fuck up like the 3G iPod’s 4 buttons which were swiftly and smartly replaced by the very awesome click wheel. Good luck, Apple…