That last post got me wondering about what’s happening to our country, and if this next election is really going to make any difference at all. My contention when people start up with me about politics is both a great cop-out and a call to arms. Essentially it’s time for all of us, as a nation, to choose the path of our destiny to come in this new century. We need to decide if we’re all in this together or if we’re going to go it alone. The current administration is demonstrably all about going it alone. Welfare’s been cut, we start wars essentially by ourselves in favor of our own interests, taxes for the wealthy decreased. “You’re on your own,” Bush and Cheney say. And maybe that’s okay. This nation was founded on the principles of liberty and independence. 1776 was all about going it alone. But something happened seven score and thirteen years after that: we started to decide that we all might need some help every now and then. And maybe that’s okay, too. But the mix just isn’t working out.
That’s the battle line that was clearly drawn 70 years ago. The New Deal brought us Social Security, the WPA, and helped get us out of the Great Depression. FDR’s New Deal noted a shift in American thinking. Some of us began to move away from rugged individualism and self-reliance. The Great Depression and the laissez-faire policies that bred it had begun to teach us that maybe we couldn’t just go it alone, maybe we did need a little help from our friends. Not a handout, not a free ride—we all wanted to work, make an honest living, be self reliant and individuals, but some Americans agreed that it wasn’t always possible to do so. Thus an America was born that believed both in the individual and the community. The greatest outcome of this was our entry into World War II: we were no longer an isolated country going it alone—the world needed us. We in turn needed it.
But the world has changed so much since then, and the system we set up is on the verge of collapse. The socio-economic safety net is no longer as strong as it used to be, and it’s straining under the weight of so many disadvantaged Americans. And maybe that’s okay. Capitalism is still up and running—the economy is in fact growing. So maybe it’s okay to say “Sorry you can’t make it, but you’re on your own.” I personally think that would be okay, but only if that meant everyone truly had every opportunity. If we’re going to chose that path, we need to make sure there’s a job for everyone to do, a way for everyone to go their own way. Otherwise as a nation we’re doomed. There isn’t anything wrong with wanting to make your own way in life, but if there’s nowhere to go then our society simply won’t function. We’ll buckle under the weight of our own poor. Capitalism won’t work if just a few have money to spend.
On the other hand, maybe it’s not okay. We’re the richest country in the world but still only 1% of the population controls 99% of the wealth. The other 99% of people are left fighting over that 1%, and without a way to even the odds I fail to see how we all could possibly go it alone. Besides, in the long view we’re all horribly dependent on each other, and we are too great a nation to be so simple and short sighted. Disasters like 9/11 and Katrina are supposed to show us how much we need each other. Sometime after the rubble stopped smoking and the mud dried we forgot that. Instead of rebuilding together we looted the cities and rioted in the Superdome. Instead of finding hope and togetherness were told to go shopping. Katrina even split apart an entire region of our country. Somehow, in the span of 70 years we became a weaker nation. We cannot allow the worst of us to get the best of us.
Forget about jobs and education, immigration and gay marriage; how can we even begin to come together when we let something as simple and commonplace as wind and rain drive us apart?
Most of all, things like excellent public education, accessible (and affordable) public health, and support for the arts as well as private enterprise are all public goods that help us balance our moral budget. We near the brink when there are more people in prison than in college, when we spend more on war than peace, when more of us are hungry than fed, when we’re afraid when we should be hopeful.
Something happened in 1929 that forced us to do so. Our nation’s finest hours came in the nearly twenty years after The Crash when we were able to take a great loss and turn it into a great victory. We’ve had that chance this century and thus far we’ve squandered it. So maybe this next election will be our chance to transform our defeat and despair into the triumph that makes America unique in the history of nations.
Ken Burns, when interviewed in USA Today about his new documentary, said eight words that describe modern America’s problem better than anything I’ve ever read anywhere. He said “There’s too much Pluribus and not enough Unum.” I’ll sure second that! I’ll even say when it starts: it starts when we begin teaching our children (in public and in private) that we’re all in this together. We are one nation, regardless of whether or not you want to believe it’s “Under God,” we need to find a way to be indivisible again.


